Doctor Zebra > Presidential health > List of Presidents > Abraham Lincoln > More Back to Abraham Lincoln
 
    The Health and Medical History of President
   

Abraham Lincoln: "Milk Sick" Mother

   
 

 Odds 
&
 Ends 
Some family history (fully discussed in [33y] [34q]):
  • Many Lincolns died young: his mother Nancy (age 34), his son Eddie (age 3), his son Willie (age 11), and his son Tad (age 18).
  • Nancy Hanks Lincoln died during an epidemic of "milk sickness," caused by drinking the milk of cows feeding on poisonous plants. It is not clear, however, that she died of milk sickness. Some of the people who told Herndon about Nancy's death had other opinions, and it can be seen that Herndon told absolutely nothing about her signs and symptoms . Fear of the milk sickness' return seems to have been a factor in the surviving Lincolns' decision to move from Indiana to Illinois in 1830 [9e].
  • Eddie died after a 52-day illness that the 1850 census recorded as "chronic consumption." This old-fashioned term is compatible with both tuberculosis and cancer. Eddie was tall, and had the type of lips seen in MEN2B.
  • Willie died in the White House from an acute infection, probably typhoid fever. He had survived scarlet fever in 1860. He had long legs, and had the type of lips seen in MEN2B.
  • Tad died of progressive respiratory distress, caused by fluid around his lungs and possibly his heart. This was most likely a malignant effusion that arose from medullary thyroid cancer that had spread into his chest. Tad had the type of lips seen in MEN2B. Earlier, Tad had contracted, but survived, the illness that killed his brother Willie in 1862
  • Lincoln's oldest son, Robert, lived to age 82. His lips were normal. There is a tradition in Terre Haute, IN that Lincoln brought young Robert there to be treated with a "mad stone" after a dog bite, possibly in September 1859.
  • Abraham Lincoln's last direct descendent died in 1985.

More...

Today, the milk sickness is known to result from Eupatorium rugosum, the white snakeroot. Cattle that eat this plant can pass a toxin to humans.

In Lincoln's time, this was not known. The Lincoln biography co-authored by his law partner, William Herndon [9f], describes the milk sickness:

In the fall of 1818, the scantily settled region in the vicinity of Pigeon Creek [Indiana] ... suffered a visitation of that dread disease common in the West in early days, and known in the vernacular of the frontier as "the milk sick."

It hovered like a spectre over the Pigeon Creek settlement for over ten years, and its fatal visitation and inroads among the Lincolns, Hankses, and Sparrows finally drove that contingent into Illinois.

To this day the medical profession has never agreed upon any definite cause for the malady, nor have they in all their scientific wrangling determined exactly what the disease itself is. A physician, who has in his practice met a number of cases, describes the symptoms to be "a whitish coat on the tongue, burning sensation of the stomach, severe vomiting, obstinate constipation of the bowels, coolness of the extremities, great restlessness and jactitation, pulse rather small, somewhat more frequent than natural, and lightly chorded. In the course of the disease the coat on the tongue becomes brownish and dark, the countenance dejected, and the prostration of the patient is great. A fatal termination may take place in sixty hours, or life may be prolonged for a period of fourteen days. These are the symptoms of the disease in an acute form. Sometimes it runs into the chronic form, or it may assume that form from the commencement, and after months or years the patient may finally die or recover only a partial degree of health."

In October 1818, Lincoln's mother became ill. He was then nine years old. Herndon continues [9g]:
Her sufferings, however, were destined to be of brief duration. Within a week she too rested from her labors. ... Abe and his sister Sarah waited on their mother, and did the little jobs and errands required of them. There was no physician nearer than thirty-five miles. The mother knew she was going to die, and called the children to her bedside. She was very weak, and the children leaned over while she gave her last message.
Herndon was a tireless researcher, but modern historians believe he sometimes over-dramatized facts.
Amid the miserable surroundings of a home in the wilderness Nancy Hanks passed across the dark river. Though of lowly birth, the victim of poverty and hard usage, she takes a place in history as the mother of a son who liberated a race of men. [9h]

A decade later, milk sickness was still present:

The winter of 1829 was marked by abother visitation of that dreaded disease, "the milk sick." It was making the usual ravages among the cattle. Human victims were falling before it every day, and it caused the usual stampede in southern Indiana. Dennis Hanks, discouraged by the prospect and grieving over the loss of his stock, proposed a move further westward. Returning emigrants had brought encouraging news of the newly developed state of Illinois. ... The proposition of Dennis met with the general assent of the Lincoln family. [9i]

     Resources[Top]
Disclosure: Doctor Zebra gets a few pennies if you click & buy from Amazon.
  1. Boller, Paul F. Jr. Presidential Anecdotes. New York: Oxford University Press, 1981. ISBN 0-19-502915-1 @ Amazon   [a] p. 133 [b] p. 125

  2. Bumgarner, John R. The Health of the Presidents: The 41 United States Presidents Through 1993 from a Physician's Point of View. Jefferson, NC: MacFarland & Company, 1994. ISBN 0-89950-956-8 @ Amazon   [a] p. 89 [b] pp. 91-94 [c] p. 95
        Devotes one chapter to each President, through Clinton. Written for the layperson, well-referenced, with areas of speculation clearly identified, Dr. Zebra depends heavily on this book. Dr. Bumgarner survived the Bataan Death March and has written an unforgettable book casting a physician's eye on that experience.

  3. Davidson, Glen W. Abraham Lincoln and the DNA controversy. Journal of the Abraham Lincoln Association. 1996;17(1):1-26.

  4. Fishman RS; Da Silveira A. Lincoln's craniofacial microsomia. Arch Ophthalmol. 2007; 125: 1126-1130.

  5. Gary, Ralph. Following Lincoln's Footsteps. New York: Carroll & Graf, 2001. ISBN 0-7867-09413 @ Amazon   [a] p. 227 [b] p. 58 [c] p. 313 this comment was from soldiers in Fredericksburg, VA, April 1863 [d] p. 397 [e] pp. 66, 398 [f] p. 177 [g] p. 68 [h] p. 4 [i] pp. 322, 323-324 [j] pp. 9-10

  6. Goldstein JH. Lincoln's vertical strabismus. J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus. 1997 Mar-Apr;34(2):118-20.

  7. Good, Timothy S. (ed). We Saw Lincoln Shot. Jackson, MS: University of Mississippi Press, 1995. ISBN 0-87805-778-1 @ Amazon

  8. Gordon AM. Abraham Lincoln: a medical appraisal. Journal of the Kentucky Medical Association. 1962;60:249-253. Pubmed.
        A brilliant work of historical research and medical deduction. MEN2B was unknown in 1962, so Gordon got as close as he could.

  9. Herndon, William H. and Weik, Jesse W. Herndon's Life of Lincoln. Cleveland: World Publishing, 1942 (originally published 1888).   [a] p. 18 [b] p. 247 [c] p. 250 [d] p. 48 [e] p. 56 [f] pp. 25-26 [g] pp. 26-27 [h] pp. 27 [i] pp. 56-57

  10. Hirschhorn N, Feldman RG, Greaves IA. Abraham Lincoln's blue pills: did our 16th President suffer from mercury poisoning?. Perspect Biol Med. 2001;44:315-332. Pubmed.

  11. Kunhardt, Philip B, et al. Lincoln: An Illustrated Biography. NY: Alfred A. Knopf, 1992. ISBN 0-679-40862-2 @ Amazon   [a] p. 356

  12. Lamon, Ward Hill. Recollections of Abraham Lincoln. Washington, DC: Dorothy Lamon Teillard, 1911.   [a] p. 161 [b] p. 136

  13. Lattimer JK. Lincoln did not have Marfan syndrome; documented evidence. N Y State J Med. 1981;81:1805-1813. Pubmed.
        A failed challenge to the idea that Lincoln was marfanoid.

  14. Lattimer, John K. Kennedy and Lincoln: Medical & Ballistic Comparisons of Their Assassinations. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1980. ISBN 0-15-152281-2 @ Amazon

  15. MacMahon, Edward B. and Curry, Leonard. Medical Cover-Ups in the White House. Washington, DC: Farragut, 1987. ISBN 0-918535-01-8 @ Amazon   [a] p. 19

  16. Marion, Robert. Was George Washington Really the Father of our Country?. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1994. ISBN 0-201-62255-6 @ Amazon   [a] pp. 88-124 [b] p. 100 [c] pp. 108, 110. Marion believes Lincoln had mitral valve prolapse syndrome, which shares some of the skeletal features of Marfan syndrome. [d] p. 93 [e] p. 104

  17. McKusick, Victor A. Mendelian Inheritance in Man. 9th ed. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990.
        Later print editions have appeared, e.g. the 12th in 1998: Amazon (ISBN is 0801857422). The entire contents are freely available on the web as "Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM)." The online version is more current than the printed version.

  18. McKusick VA. Advisory statement by the panel on DNA testing of Abraham Lincoln's tissue. Caduceus. 1991;7(1 Spring):43-47. Pubmed.

  19. McKusick VA. Abraham Lincoln and Marfan syndrome. Nature. 1991;352:280 only.

  20. Web page: http://www.mrlincolnswhitehouse.org/content_inside.asp?ID=217&subjectID=3
    (Mr Lincoln's White House.org)

  21. Myers, James E. The Amazing Saber Duel of Abraham Lincoln. Lincoln-Herndon Building, 1968.
        Cited by Gary.

  22. Neely, Mark E. Jr. Rattling Lincoln's bones. Lincoln Lore: Bulletin of the Louis A. Warren Lincoln Library and Museum. August 1990; nbr 1818:1-4.

  23. Pyeritz RE, McKusick VA. The Marfan syndrome: diagnosis and management. N Engl J Med. 1979;300:772-777. Pubmed.

  24. Pendel, Thomas F. Thirty-Six Years in the White House. Washington: Neale Publishing Company, 1902.   [a] pp. 35-37
        Pendel was door-keeper at the White House from the time of Lincoln to the time of Theodore Roosevelt. Full text is available on-line at loc.gov. It's a rather dry book, and reads as if it were written by an old man. http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/D?lhbcbbib:1:./temp/~ammem_rEou::

  25. Rafuse, Ethan S. Typhoid and turmoil: Lincoln's response to General McClellan's bout with typhoid fever during the winter of 1861-62. Journal of the Abraham Lincoln Association. 1997;18(2):1-16.

  26. Ready T. Access to Presidential DNA denied. Nature Medicine. 1999;5:859. Pubmed.

  27. Schwartz H. Abraham Lincoln and the Marfan syndrome. Journal of the American Medical Association. 1964;187:473-479. Pubmed.

  28. Schwartz H. Abraham Lincoln and aortic insufficiency. The declining health of the President. California Medicine. 1972;166(5):82-84. Pubmed.

  29. Schwartz H. Abraham Lincoln and cardiac decompensation: a preliminary report. West J Med. 1978:128(2):174-177. Pubmed.

  30. Seldes, George. Witness to a Century. New York: Ballantine, 1987. ISBN 0-345-33181-8 @ Amazon   [a] p. 245
        In 1927 Katherine Medill McCormick recalled to a group of people that her mother used to say this -- and several other disparaging things about the President -- before sending her to play with the Lincoln children. McCormick's father, Joseph Medill, was a friend of Lincoln's. Lincoln was not alone in being an object of Mrs. Medill's scorn. Seldes makes it clear that she hated just about everyone and everything.

  31. Shenk, Joshua Wolf. Lincoln's Melancholy. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2005. ISBN 0618551166 @ Amazon

  32. Shutes, Milton H. Lincoln and the Doctors: A Medical Narrative of the Life of Abraham Lincoln. New York: Pioneer Press, 1933.   [a] pp. 7-8

  33. Sotos, John G. The Physical Lincoln: Finding the Genetic Cause of Abraham Lincoln's Height, Homeliness, Pseudo-Depression, and Imminent Cancer Death. Mt. Vernon, VA: Mt. Vernon Book Systems, 2008.   [a] p. 57 (Volk's memory is known as not entirely trustworthy) [b] pp. 223-227 [c] pp. 44-81 [d] p. 44 [e] p. 45-48 [f] pp. 52-63 [g] pp. 84-115 [h] pp. 117-121 [i] pp. 77-80 [j] pp. 206-233 [k] pp. 87-89 [l] pp. 80-81 [m] pp. 194-205 [n] p. 167 [o] pp. 164-173 [p] pp. 252-257 [q] pp. 67-68 [r] p. 138-139 [s] pp. 158-163 [t] p. 102 [u] pp. 96-105 [v] p. 102-103 [w] p. 157 [x] pp. 49, 122, 187 [y] pp. 106-115, 140-145
        More information at: http://www.physical-lincoln.com/

  34. Sotos, John G. The Physical Lincoln Sourcebook. Mt. Vernon, VA: Mt. Vernon Book Systems, 2008.   [a] pp. 66-67 [b] pp. 190-191, 313 [c] p. 191 quoting primary sources [d] p. 118 [e] p. 71 [f] pp. 118, 313-315 [g] pp. 318-326 [h] p. 26 (¶73) [i] pp. 195-198 [j] pp. 191-192 quoting all sources [k] p. 56, quoting Elizabeth Todd Grimsley [l] pp. 335-351 [m] p. 340 [n] pp. 88-89 [o] pp. 57-58, 86-87 (633, 635, 1199-1216) [p] p. 177-179 [q] pp. 206-310
        More information at: http://www.physical-lincoln.com/

  35. Tarbell, Ida. Abraham Lincoln and His Ancestors. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska, 1997.   [a] p. 185
        Originally published 1924 as In the Footsteps of the Lincolns.

  36. The Abraham Lincoln web page at the White House.

  37.  (64 matches when checked in November 2003)
  [Top]

<== James BuchananReturn to Abraham LincolnAndrew Johnson ==>

George Washington · John Adams · Thomas Jefferson · James Madison · James Monroe · John Q. Adams · Andrew Jackson · Martin van Buren · William Harrison · John Tyler · James Polk · Zachary Taylor · Millard Fillmore · Franklin Pierce · James Buchanan · Abraham Lincoln · Andrew Johnson · Ulysses Grant · Rutherford Hayes · James Garfield · Chester Arthur · Grover Cleveland · Benjamin Harrison · William McKinley · Theodore Roosevelt · William Taft · Woodrow Wilson · Warren Harding · Calvin Coolidge · Herbert Hoover · Franklin Roosevelt · Harry Truman · Dwight Eisenhower · John Kennedy · Lyndon Johnson · Richard Nixon · Gerald Ford · James Carter · Ronald Reagan · George Bush · William Clinton · George W. Bush · Barack Obama
Others: Cheney · McCain

Dr Zebra | Prez Home | Search | Contact us | Back | Top

Copyright (c) 2000-2009 by DoctorZebra.com. All Rights Reserved. This page last modified May 10, 2008.